There are concerns that the most recent work undertaken as part of the EU Tobacco Products Directive (TPD) both contradicts and ignores a number of industry inputs and previous recommendations to combat the illicit trade in tobacco products.
In response to the public consultation being organised by the EC’s Directorate General for Health and Food Safety (DG Santé), the International Tax Stamp Association has raised a number of legal and technical concerns over the options included in the Inception Impact Assessment published earlier this year to assist with the implementation of a secondary legislation for traceability and security features, as required under Articles 15 and 16 of the EU TPD.
Among the key anomalies highlighted by ITSA is that the Assessment fails to fully take into consideration the provisions of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC), now ratified by the EU, which clearly disqualifies some of the governance model options now being contemplated.
In addition, ITSA is concerned that the public consultation survey appears to favour information technologies exclusively – something that completely ignores best practice and previous work carried out on supply chain authentication technologies.
For example, an EC feasibility study published in 2015 that recognised the potential benefits of combining TPD requirements with existing Member State tax stamp programmes was not mentioned in the Inception Impact Assessment.
Nicola Sudan, General Secretary of ITSA, said: “We believe it is important to raise the fact that over 20 EU member states currently use tobacco tax stamps, most of which already carry – or have the potential to carry – a combination of the kind of material-based security features and digital technologies that will be required under the TPD.
“In addition, by being positioned over the opening of a tobacco package, the stamps act as an anti-tampering seal, which is another requirement of the Directive.”
Since the great majority of tobacco manufacturers are already equipped with tax stamp applicators on their production lines, ITSA says that any continued use of this equipment for reasons of TPD compliance would be neither over-burdensome nor costly to manufacturers.
In addition, tax stamp technologies can be used by small and large producers alike and take account of the need for a level playing field, avoiding unfair advantage to a minority of largeoligopolistic actors in the tobacco market.
In summary, Nicola Sudan said: “ITSA believes that truly robust solutions must combine material and digital security technologies - a view that is recognised by both the WHO FCTC and the EU TPD.
“This union of physical and digital features is essential to ensure that the combined objectives of authentication, traceability and tamper-evidence is achieved – which is something that information technologies alone are not able to do.”
The Evolution of Brand Protection: The Emergence of a New Generation and a Unique New Technology
StellaGuard™ Security Label from Covectra: Converging Smart Technologies To Provide Universal Brand Protection
Who’s Infiltrating Your Supply Chain?
The smartphone: a new tool to spot fake products
Leveraging anti-counterfeiting technology to secure the serialized supply chain for pharmaceuticals
How Manufacturers Should Work Closely with the Big 3 and HDMA Wholesalers to Comply with DSCSA in 2017 and Beyond - Part 2
How Data Standards, Serialization & Authentication Correlate in Coding of Products
Serialization for the Premium Beverage Industry: A Solution for Brand Integrity
Tamper-proof Pharmaceutical Packaging: FMD & the Future of Closure Seals Standardization
NEW REPORT: Taggants / Forensic Markers for Anti-Counterfeit, BP, Product Authentication, Diversion Detection & Overall Product Security
Security Paper Market by Security Feature, Application and Region - Global Forecast to 2021
Food Authenticity Market by Target Testing, Technology, Food Tested and Region - Global Forecast to 2022
Smart Label Market Analysis by Technology, by Component, by Application, by End-user & Segment Forecasts 2014 - 2025
Global Market Study on Holographic Films: Pharma End Use Industry Segment to Increase 2.2X in Terms of Value over Forecast Period
Pharmaceutical Packaging Market by Product Type - Global Opportunity Analysis and Industry Forecast, 2014-2022
Anti-Counterfeit Packaging Market by Technology, Usage Feature, End-use Sector and Region - Global Forecast to 2021
Europe Portable Counterfeit Detector Market Report 2016
Nano & Other Innovative Anti-Counterfeit Technologies 2016: 40 Anti-Counterfeit & Track-and-Trace Technologies for 15+ Industry Sectors
Global EPedigree Software Market 2016-2020
Pharmaceutical Anti-Counterfeiting Technologies Market Forecast 2016-2026: RFID, Taggants, Barcodes, Holograms/OVD & Others
Wines & Spirits - Anti-Counterfeit, Brand Protection & Product Authentication
The Future of Global Security Printing Markets to 2020
Food Traceability Technologies Market 2015-2025: EAN / UPC Barcodes, 2D QR Codes, RFID & RTLS
Luxury Accessories, Beauty & Apparel: Anti-Counterfeit & Brand Protection
Global Anti-counterfeit Packaging Market 2015-2019
World Anti-counterfeit Pharma & Cosmetics Packaging - Market Opportunities & Forecasts, 2014-2020
Anti counterfeit, brand protection & tamper evident solutions
Global Anti-Counterfeit Packaging Market in Security Documents & Event Ticketing: 2014-2020
Anti-Counterfeit Packaging Technologies Market Forecast 2014-2024 & Future Prospects for Leading Companies
Mobile Advertising / Promotions and Consumer Enabled Product Authentication with Smart Phones
20th Anti-Counterfeiting & Brand Protection Summit
Jan.29-31, 2018 - San Francisco (CA), USA
Pharmapack Europe 2018
Feb.07-08, 2018 - Paris, France
Feb.22-23, 2018 - Las Vegas (NV), USA
Food Fraud 2018: A global insight
Mar.01, 2018 - London, UK
4th Anti-Counterfeiting Pharma 2018
Mar.06-07, 2018 - London, UK
Anti-Counterfeiting Forum 9th Annual Seminar
Mar.15, 2018 - Farnborough, UK
Pharma Security World 2018: "Anti-counterfeiting and Brand Safety"
Mar.20-21, 2018 - London, UK
Global Illicit Trade Summit 2018: Out of the shadows
Mar.22, 2018 - Kuala Lumpur
Apr.17-19, 2018 - New York (NY), USA
4th Global Brand Protection EU Innovation Programme (GBPIP)
Apr.26-27, 2018 - London, UK
May 29 - June 01, 2018 - Milan, Italy
Jun.25-27, 2018 - London, UK
Sep.2018 (dates tbc) - Switzerland
Anti-Counterfeit & Currency Expo (ACCE)
Nov.06-08, 2018 - Las Vegas (NV), USA